SanDisk Ultra II Plus Review
Treo accessories reviews
Social bookmarking:
or « Astraware Announces Support for Mobile Linux & Joins ACCESS Connect Ecosystem Program | Treo Software Updates from Palm »
or I have long thought of myself as a geek but I think I might of hit a new level of geekdom. I have gotten excited about a memory card. Before any of you start worrying about my sanity, I'd better explain the source of my excitement. The card in question is a 1GB SanDisk Ultra II Plus SD card and the special thing about this card is that it can plug straight into the USB socket of any PC.
When you want to use the SD card with a PC just fold it in half to reveal a USB connector. How cool is that?! There is no need to rummage around looking for your card reader or sync cable: just put the card into a USB slot on a computer and that is when the card gets recognized as a flash drive. As long as the computer in question is capable of recognizing flash drives there is no need to install any software on the PC, so that covers all the modern flavors of Windows, Mac OS and Linux. To help you use it as a flash drive it even has a cool little blue LED to show it's active.
As this is a high-end card SanDisk include a useful little key-chain card holder as well as the normal SD card case. Generally, I do not carry spare cards around with me as I worry about losing them. After testing this holder for two weeks I have decided next time I need to carry a spare card it'll be kept safe in this convenient holder. Although it looks fairly flimsy it's well made and securely holds onto any card stored in it.
My usual day to day SD card is a standard 2GB SanDisk Ultra II card so I thought I'd compare the speed of this to the 1GB SanDisk Ultra II Plus card. I used the freeware application VFSmark to compare the speed of the blank cards in my Treo 680. The Ultra II Plus card gave a respectable score of 509 - marginally quicker than my current Ultra II card's score of 506. Such high scores mean both cards are quick enough for any demands your Treo can throw at them.As both cards are branded SanDisk Ultra II I expected to get similar results when I tested the data transfer speeds using a PC. I tested how long it took to transfer a directory containing 92.9MB in 605 files. Before each test I formatted the card to ensure consistent results.
Ultra II with card reader 152 seconds
Ultra II plus with card reader 278 seconds
Ultra II plus USB mode 256 seconds
I repeated each test twice and the results were consistent: the Ultra II Plus card was always 70-80% slower than a standard Ultra II card. I guess how important an issue this is depends on how often you would want to transfer a large amount of data. Personally, I found the added convenience of the USB connector more than made up for the slower transfer rate. Since getting this card I have found myself carrying a normal USB flash drive less at work. If I need to transfer some files I just get out my Treo and pop out the SD card.
Obviously, this extra USB functionality does not come for free; comparing the 512MB SanDisk Ultra II cards in the mytreo.net store the standard version costs $37.95 and the Plus version costs $44.95. I'd happily pay an extra $7 for the convenience of the built-in USB connector. At $64.95 the 1GB Ultra II Plus is not the cheapest SD card around, but I think it's a reasonable price for such a high specification card.
If you are in the market for a 512MB-2GB capacity high specification SD card, I'd recommend considering this card.
Related Links
1GB SanDisk Ultra II Plus SD card
or Tek Holster - Jun 16, 2008
Sena Treo flip top case - Mar 19, 2008
Seidio Crystal case for Treo 680 - Mar 15, 2008
We have Prima's new Centro cases! (Review.) - Mar 05, 2008
Two Great Cases from Seidio for Your Centro - Mar 02, 2008
Comments
christo says:
I've had the 1 gigger for almost a year now? I've loved the card and ability to use it as a flash drive or to add files without using hotsync or a card reader. I would recommend saving the receipt though, cause it finally started having some problems. First, I lost the lock/unlock slider from the card. I use tape now :(
Second, the card actually popped open where the hinge for the USB fold is located. I used some silicon to keep it working till I can get a new one.... waiting for the 2 gig price to drop and I'll go for it I think....just keep my receipt this time!
christo says:
I've had the 1 gigger for almost a year now? I've loved the card and ability to use it as a flash drive or to add files without using hotsync or a card reader. I would recommend saving the receipt though, cause it finally started having some problems. First, I lost the lock/unlock slider from the card. I use tape now :(
Second, the card actually popped open where the hinge for the USB fold is located. I used some silicon to keep it working till I can get a new one.... waiting for the 2 gig price to drop and I'll go for it I think....just keep my receipt this time!
bpb21 says:
I've had the same for some time now. I try not to "overuse" that USB interface for the exact same reason christo points out above. Still, it's nice to have the option if you want to back up your entire SD card and don't have a card reader handy. I'd recommend them.
Joad says:
"Limited lifetime warranty."
hey christo - if you're still alive Sandisk would have a hard time denying warranty rights to you, the things haven't even been out a couple years or so. Just call up Sandisk, tell them about where and when you bought it- their warranty support is a bit slow but you should be able to stick to your guns and get a replacement.
I had a corsair SD that began falling apart (chipping and cracking open) months after buying - and it was rarely used. I just contacted the company, got an RMA and sent it to them. Had a new card a week or so later that seems to be holding up. Unless it's obviousl user abuse, they should be held to their warranties, especially lifetime!
jimmyjames213 says:
lol you actually pay for those
I got a 4gb card for like $45 ya it might not be as fast as yours but its dirt cheap and it 4gb insted of one or two
I had a 1gb sandisk ultra II and I can't tell the diff when I'm useing my treo
I say memory over speed
and as for the usb function big deal
almost every comp now a days has a sd card reader (at least at my house/neighborhood :)
Joad says:
Prices of this stuff are always dropping. And I have a sense that the Treo's SD bus doesn't really take advantage of speeds over a certain rating anyhow.
But it's a bigger number and that's better, right? :)
Apparently Sandisk doesn't use SLC, which is probably a better reason to choose another brand. The design of this USB/SD card was doomed to physical failure just by it's nature - how long can a hinge like this last? The Tungsten 1, 2 and 3's had the same sort of issues - some cheap electronic things should just be designed without movement. Palm figured they could deny their problems as "out of warranty" or "user caused," but Sandisk may not have that luxury.
dmets says:
I have 4 of these - I love them. Without carrying anything other than my phone - I always have a USB drive available - no extra cables or software. Plus quick transfers. (I have a SD camera as well).
I use one of these cards with mypodder from podcastready.com. I can be anywhere - work, home, library anyplace with an internet connection and usb port and I can update my podcasts. No need for hotsync or other cable. Just unplug the card, fold gently and plug it in the USB slot.
As to the quality of the card or hinge - yeah - its small and plastic. So treat it with some respect. Don't manhandle it. I have had 5 cards - one broke because I forgot it was plugged into to my notebook's USB port and tilted the notebook to pick it up - SNAP. Otherwise - these things are great and sturdy enough for normal use.
Dustin
Login to post a comment
You are not currently logged in to mytreo.net. To post comments please login below or register.